
Two weeks ago, late to the zeitgeist as ever, I watched My Octopus Teacher, the Oscar-winning documentary about a relationship between a human and a cephalopod. Probably you’ve seen it (and if not, you should!), but, in brief, it’s about the yearlong friendship filmmaker Craig Foster strikes up with a female common octopus who lives in a South African kelp forest. The fascination (and, dare I say, affection) is mutual: The film’s most stirring shots depict the octopus clinging to Foster’s hand and sprawling against his chest, a pose that’s hard to describe as anything other than “cuddling.” It’s a gorgeous movie, and, as an octopus-loving diver myself, I watched it with a lump in my throat, both admiring and envious of Foster’s interspecies connection.
That said, there were two scenes that left me dismayed, and have continued to rankle since I watched the film. I’m talking about the shark attacks, and, specifically, Foster’s refusal to protect the octopus.
For the uninitiated (spoilers to follow), the kelp forest is also inhabited by packs of pyjama sharks, beautiful little black-and-white predators with a sense of smell that would awe a bloodhound. The sharks are the greatest threat to the octopus’s survival; they’re constantly sniffing around her rocky lair and trying to pry her out. Twice, they nearly succeed in killing her. The first time, one seizes her in his jaws, goes into a death roll, and rips off one of her arms. The octopus survives, but on death’s door (happily, she recovers and eventually regrows the arm). During the second attack, the film’s most astonishing sequence, the octopus reaches deep into her bag of tricks to escape: She crawls on land, camouflages herself beneath shells, and, incredibly, rides on the oblivious shark’s back. The scene has the vibe of Jerry outwitting Tom; all she needs is a falling anvil.
In the end, the octopus endures the attacks and lives long enough to breed. No harm, no foul, I guess. Still, I was disturbed that Foster never chased away the sharks. (Pyjama sharks aren’t exactly great whites; he could’ve run them off at no personal risk.) His friend, or at least his playmate, was assaulted, and he did nothing to save her.
Continue reading




