Up

What kind of music do you listen to when going to see monarchs? I can’t figure out the answer. It’s before dawn, and I’m fumbling around in the car in the dark, and finally I decide to just let my phone play whatever it’s going to play. I turn my headlights on and pull away from the curb, and just then the song title flashes across the dashboard screen: UP!

That’s what the hope is for the butterflies that I’m going to see. I’m meeting a group of researchers and monarch lovers as part of a butterfly tagging project at Ellwood Mesa, an open space with eucalyptus groves that host overwintering monarch butterflies.

We’re meeting early because it’s easiest to catch butterflies when it’s cool. Once the day warms, they’ll begin fluttering off the eucalyptus branches, where they cluster like grapes.

In the half-light, research biologist Charis van der Heide lashes a butterfly net to the end of a telescoping 28-foot pole and hovers it beneath a small group of butterflies before gently scooping them off. It’s 58 degrees at 6:15 a.m. — already a little too warm, she says, and then recounts an anxiety dream she had the night before, where it was 80 degrees at sunrise — so the rest of us are on scout duty, in case one of the butterflies heats up and drifts away from the group to the ground.

As she counts the butterflies from this harvest, six in all, their wings begin to flutter. “They’re already waking up,” she says.

She’s looking for five males and five females to tag with radio transmitters, so that their movements can be tracked by Project Monarch, a collaboration of organizations across North America. The tags allow researchers to follow monarchs across the year and across the continent, from migration to overwintering, migration to summer breeding.

At Ellwood Mesa, where butterflies spend the winter after migrating from their summer breeding ground in places like Idaho, Nevada, and Arizona, “we want to look at overwintering behavior on an individual basis,” van der Heide says. “When they use a site, how long are they there? How often? Do they leave a site every day? Do they go to specific locations for nectar or water and then come back? How far do they go before they don’t come back?”

What they learn about overwintering monarchs could help them not only understand more about these butterflies’ life cycle and movements, but could also identify areas of habitat that are critical to keep butterfly populations healthy. From the data, researchers could determine how much habitat needs to be protected, whether there are sites that should be enhanced with nectar-rich, winter-flowering plants or milkweed. And they might be able to solve a butterfly mystery: where monarchs go immediately after overwintering. “Knowing where they go is a first step to how can we better conserve their habitat,” she says.  

Butterfly tags

But how do you put a tag on something that small?  A monarch butterfly weighs about as much as a pumpkin seed, so the tags are even smaller, less that 18 percent of their body weight. Today, van der Heide and her colleague, Fiona Reidy — they work for the biological and environmental consulting firm Althouse and Meade — will attach these tags to each butterfly’s abdomen. Once the butterflies flutter off, the solar-powered tag will send out signals to radio telemetry towers in the MOTUS and to smartphones through the Project Monarch app, allowing users to pinpoint the butterfly’s location and follow their movements.

I’ve been following other tagged butterflies on Project Monarch’s app for the past week. There’s one named Lulu that flew all the way from southern Idaho to the Central Coast, a journey of 1,000 kilometers.

Eastern monarchs are known for even more extensive migrations, traveling all the way from Canada to Mexico in the winter, and then, over a series of generations, back to Canada in the summer. Lulu, and the butterflies being tagged today, are part of the less-studied western migratory population, which makes understanding their movements even more critical, particularly as the past few winters have brought steep declines in California butterfly populations.

 Van der Heide gently captures a few more clusters in her net, each time she separates males and females into two different containers, and releases butterflies that have visible wing damage. Above us, jets from the nearby airport begin to roar overhead, drowning out the bird song as they find their own flight paths.

There are only five females, while the container with males is flecked with monarchs. She reaches for one more cluster in the trees. “I’m feeling good about this one. Very feminine.” But when she looks through her net, the entire group is males, which she releases. “I think we’ve woken up enough of the roosting monarchs and we’ll leave the rest undisturbed,” she says.

We head up the hill to a fenced-off area, where she and Reidy set up a table and scale to measure and weigh the butterflies before they’re tagged, to make sure the tag won’t be too much ballast.

How do you do all this with something as light as a butterfly? Carefully, but not as carefully as you might think. It’s a misunderstanding, van der Heide says, that butterflies are exquisitely fragile. These same wings can carry them 100 miles a day. Storms, high winds, bird beaks — sometimes their wings are tattered, their scales damaged, but many of them fly on.

Van der Heide pins the wings together between two fingers as she measures the wing from abdomen to wingtip, then she holds the abdomen as she examines the wings for damage and the condition of the scales. 

Each butterfly also gets a small sample taken from its abdomen with a clear sticker, the kind used to seal envelopes, which then gets pressed against an index card. The researchers are looking for spores of the parasite Ophryocystis elektroscirrha, or OE, which infects monarchs and other butterflies. A caterpillar eats spores of OE, which then release the parasite into the caterpillar’s gut. Once the caterpillar builds itself into its chrysalis, the parasite can damage growing wings and so that the emerging butterfly’s wings are crumpled or undersized. They fly poorly, if they fly at all.

Under a small scope, the spores look like little black dots scattered among the arcs of scales. The researchers are looking for ones with minimal to no infection to tag. Each measured butterfly gets a letter and is put in a glassine bag, the same way they’re stored for butterfly releases. Beneath the table, there’s a cooler packed with butterflies.

Once they’re all measured, the tags go on. It’s a careful process. Each wing of the butterfly goes into a separate, smaller bag for protection, and then the butterfly is set down on a handmade board with a space for its abdomen. Small washers act like weighted blankets, keeping the butterfly calm and still while the tag is attached.

How do you attach a butterfly tag? Eyelash glue. I’ve never worn false eyelashes, but seeing the tubes of glue makes me think, for a moment, I should give it a try. As research.

 The real researchers dot glue on the back of the tag, on the thorax of the butterfly, and then press the tag down gently with the tip of a mechanical pencil. I keep writing the word gently in my notes, but I don’t know how else to describe it. Butterflies are strong, and they are also small. People want to take care of them. Another volunteer tells a story of people trying to feed butterflies with crumpled wings, trying to fix broken wings with rubber cement.

The clouds have rolled in as the tagging begins  —  rain is coming tomorrow, which is why the tagging is being done now, ahead of van der Heide’s original schedule. She wants to give the butterflies time to resettle in the grove before the storm blows in. 

Cooler weather means the glue dries slowly, so on-the-fly solutions emerge: lay the butterflies inside a warm car for now, then run to town and get a craft heat gun once the store opens. Test the heat gun on your hand, then test it on the washer to make sure they don’t get too hot. Just then, the sun comes out again, so the heat gun gets tucked away for another time.

By 11 a.m., five male and five female butterflies are tagged and ready to be released.  We take them back into the grove and Reidy and van der Heide unzip their carriers. As soon as they fly away, we all pull out our phones to see if we can see where they’ve headed.

What do you name a butterfly? Kids at a nearby school want to call one “Ellie Wood.” A local company offers up its name: Toad. There’s Maxine, and Penny, and the mysterious Fifi LeMoque.

Before I met van der Heide, I thought her first name came from a genus of metalmark butterflies, but when I ask she says it’s Greek, for charisma.

Butterflies seem drawn to her, and people, too. When we encounter a group of schoolkids visiting from Lompoc, about an hour away, in the butterfly grove, they draw near as she talks them through the process of tagging. Then she shows them the Project Monarch app on her phone.

The butterflies’ signals are pinging around the grove. There’s Penny, who flew straight toward the sunlight. There’s Ellie Wood, lingering near ELWD12. And Fifi, who’s winged her way over to someone’s backyard in a nearby neighborhood.

I keep following the butterflies for the rest of the day. As I drive home (still acting of its own accord, my car stereo starts playing a song called GOOD DAY, all caps) my phone pings with monarchs. When I’m parked in my driveway, 15 miles away, I sit and watch the butterflies on the app. I watch them again between each paragraph of this story. Maxine! Penny! ELWD11! Toad! Ellie! Their flight forms orange lines that crisscross the eucalyptus grove, scribbling across the map in the color of autumn.

What do you do when it’s really time to stop looking at where the butterflies are? I close the app and instead look at a video I took of van der Heide as she released the last group of tagged butterflies. Beneath the tree where she’d found the butterflies a few hours before, she unzips the top of the white mesh enclosure. One after another, the butterflies fly out. “Go join your friends,” she says, “Go up, up, up! UP!”

But a few monarchs still linger on the inside, gripping the mesh with the claws on the tips of their legs. She coaxes one out. For a moment, it rests on her index finger. Its wings flap — gently, strongly — until she blows at it like a stubborn birthday candle, and at last, it flies up and away.

*

top photo: Joanna Gilkeson/USFWS

other photos: Cameron Walker

Scientist in the Field: Mosquitos, Ticks, & Reservation Dogs

7921286730_c769ecfea4_c

Kathleen R. Walker, an entomologist and my stepdaughter, has moved on from mosquitoes to ticks and from Sonora, Mexico a little north to the Tohono O’odham reservation (pronounced Toe-HONO Oh-tem) in Arizona. She says the Otem for short. The dogs on the reservation, which are many and, contrary to my mental image of reservation dogs, friendly and happy and live what she thinks is an ideal doggy life: they are fed by their families and get medical care, but otherwise run free wherever dogs like to run. Some of the medical care is supplied by Kathleen and her team of students, colleagues, and volunteers; these days they vaccinate against rabies and ticks — dermacentor ticks have always carried the nasty Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, she says, but now brown dog ticks do too. Dinner with Kathleen is always educational.

Anyway, first they have to catch the dogs which is generally easy except for a few feral ones. One O’odham woman in her 80s was determined to get a non-compliant dog vaccinated, so one 108 F degree day, she spotted it, lassoed it, tackled it, and full-body held it down until it got vaccinated — Kathleen was told that story by a colleagues and she likes it. She also tells a story about dripping tick medicine along a dog’s spine, and the ticks falling off in a shower. I’m never sure how I feel about Kathleen’s stories (see aphids, below). Anyway, the following is about when she worked with mosquitoes; it first ran September 22, 2016.

I must tell you up front that Kathleen R. Walker, second author on “Aedes aegypti (Diptera: Culicidae) Longevity and Differential Emergence of Dengue Fever in Two Cities in Sonora, Mexico,” published Janusary 2017 in the Journal of Medical Entomology, is my stepdaughter.  She’s an entomologist, she studies bugs; I occasionally have a bug question.  I asked her once about those little tornadoes of gnats you see in the springtime, and she said – as I remember, so don’t hold her accountable – that they were columns of bugs in love and the bugs at the top were the ones having the most sex.  I asked her another time about the translucent aphids she showed me that were being eaten from the inside out by tiny parasitic wasps, and she said, fondly, “The aphids don’t seem to mind.  They’re awfully stupid.”

For a number of years now, she’s been working on mosquitoes and for good reason:  the ones taking over these days, Aedes aegypti, carry not only yellow fever, but also Zika, chikungunya, and a disease Kathleen R. studies, dengue.

Dengue is a virus that causes high fevers and when it’s severe, the kind of hemorrhagic fever that kills people. 100 million people get it every year; since the 1950’s the incidence has gone up by a factor of 30; and it’s spreading.  Since it’s carried by mosquitoes, the places with the most dengue ought to be the places with the most mosquitoes.  But in fact, some places that have the mosquito don’t have dengue. 

Continue reading →

back road / daily walk

This alcohol marker comics poem was conceived and completed at Storyknife Writers Retreat near Homer, Alaska. I spent the whole month of October in my own mini cabin staring out over Cook Inlet and watching the sky and the volcanoes across the water change in the weather. If you’d like to support Storyknife’s work to support women writers like me, please consider donating today. And if you’d like to support my work directly, please consider sharing this newsletter with friends, become a paid subscriber to my substack, Terra Affirma, where this post also appeared, or kick me some loose change on Buy Me Coffee. Thanks as always for reading, my friends!

How do you keep going?

Almost ten years ago, I rented an Airbnb in Beirut from a young American lawyer named Samantha, who had recently moved there from D.C. She mostly stayed at her boyfriend’s apartment, leaving me alone in her tiny place in Achrafieh, but she made me feel welcome, inviting me along on evenings with her friends.

I had come to Beirut for the final stretch of a reporting trip for Science on mental health in Syrian refugee communities. I’d spent three months visiting refugee camps in Greece, Germany and Sweden, talking to people who’d fled the war in Syria and the researchers and clinicians trying to alleviate their suffering. By the time I reached Lebanon, I was exhausted and sad. Most evenings, I found myself revisiting the fear, loss and grief I’d encountered—and trying to ignore the guilt I felt each time I returned to my hotel room, safe.

A few evenings with Samantha, without my recorder or notebook, were a huge relief. She took me to an underground bookstore where her friends—a group of burly, bearded locals—were playing Munchkin. Another night, she invited me to an acroyoga class in a cavernous warehouse, where her instructor bent her body into gravity-defying L shapes, dangling from a loop of red silk.

After a few embarrassing attempts to hoist my own body up on the silks, I gave up and watched another group using the warehouse. Dozens of children tumbled across the padded floors, doing flips and cartwheels. They were mostly refugees from Syria, the instructors told me, participating in a volunteer-led program. Earlier that day, I’d seen other children their age — also mostly refugees from Syria — teetering on the medians between lanes of traffic, approaching cars to sell roses or wash windshields.

Watching those kids brought up the same question that had come up in different ways throughout my trip: What can mental health care— and particularly the kinds of short-term programs that only last as long as humanitarian aid does — provide for people whose lives are so precarious? I never wrote about the time I spent in Lebanon for Science, but I still think about a conversation I had with the architect of its then-new national mental health program, a bespectacled psychiatrist named Rabih El Chammay. We met in the leafy, sunlit courtyard of a shopping mall near the hospital in downtown Beirut. As he described his vision for mental health care in Lebanon, speaking softly but deliberately, the bustle around us seemed to fade.

El Chammay spoke directly to the question that had been bothering me. I’d heard versions of it throughout my trip, often from people at some distance from the work: What is the value of addressing mental health in a war zone or refugee camp if people’s basic needs aren’t met? He challenged the premise: mental health and physical well-being aren’t separate things, he said, and treating them that way creates a false choice.

It might not seem visionary, in 2026, to say that poverty, physical illness and psychological suffering are intertwined. But recognizing that they’re connected is different from organizing care around them. Governments, aid organizations and funders still tend to treat mental health as an add-on, especially when funding dries up. El Chammay, who fled his own home with his parents at age six during Lebanon’s civil war, wanted to change both how mental health services were delivered and how the institutions providing them understood their responsibilities. He built an international coalition to pull that off, creating a program that many in the field admired at the time — Inka Weissbecker, then a global mental health and psychosocial adviser at International Medical Corps, described it to me as “the most promising” example of mental health reform in the Middle East.

Since my visit in 2017, Lebanon has endured economic collapse, COVID-19, the Beirut port explosion — which destroyed much of the Achrafieh neighborhood, where I stayed — and successive waves of war. El Chammay is still working toward the same goal of making mental health care accessible to everyone in Lebanon through one crisis after another.

Earlier this year, I listened to him speak at a panel on the future of humanitarian aid. The intervals between emergencies in Lebanon are now so short that there is no time to catch your breath before the next, he said. Resources are dwindling just as the need for mental health care explodes. He also surprised me by arguing that these crises have helped make some of Lebanon’s mental health reforms possible. Each emergency offers an opening to bring mental health more deeply into conversations about public health, humanitarian assistance and government responsibility. The challenge is turning those temporary surges of interest into support for institutions that endure, he said.

One reason I didn’t write about Lebanon’s program for Science was that it was still so new. It hadn’t yet generated the sorts of rigorous, measurable results that a scientific audience would find compelling—or at least that’s what my editors and I decided at the time. In hindsight, listening to El Chammay, and seeing how the entire field of global mental health has converged around the approach he’s taking, I think we might have been asking the wrong questions.

“We still think that a crisis is, like, six months to one year,” El Chammay said on the panel. “Crises are 10 to 15 years.” That is longer than most research grants, and far longer than most reporting assignments. A decade has passed since my conversation with El Chammay in that courtyard, and I have left journalism, at least for now. But he is still building that program.

I would love to ask El Chammay now about the program’s accomplishments, its shortcomings and its future. Maybe a sharp-eyed editor will assign a different reporter to call him and write about it. If they do, I hope they’ll ask deeper questions than I did: How to measure progress when the crises never stop? And how do you keep going?

Flipping the Script

I’ve been trying to say the word ‘weird’ a little less. It’s a holdover from my small town days when anything different was to be kept at arms’ length. I would rather stop disparaging things I don’t quite understand, so when I overheard my son use a modern-day synonym for ‘weird’, it struck a better chord. “I dunno, is it niche that I do that?” he asked his girlfriend. That’ll do just fine, I thought.

Language is in constant flux, sometimes changing in response to other languages it encounters, sometimes evolving through well-understood processes. It reminded me of this post, which originally ran in February 2020.

“Freak.” “Monster.” “Gorilla.” During this year’s Super Bowl Sunday, Shakira and J-Lo were not the only hyperboles on show. Both the official sports commentary and its online counterparts were littered with back-handed terms of admiration tinged with disgust. Why is it, I wondered, that these off-putting words are preferred over unambiguous compliments like ‘exceptional athlete’ and ‘outstanding contender’?

In writing this, of course, I’ve answered my own question. Undiluted positivity is boring. Even the Webster’s New World Thesaurus entry for the word “prodigy” carries these new terms, reappropriated by the muscular freakshow talents of this world: “prodigy n. marvel, portent, miracle, monster, enormity, spectacle, freak, curiosity, phenom.” (emphasis mine)

Continue reading →

The Curse of Knowledge

Amulet of Thoth, the Egyptian god of science, writing, and knowledge, represented as an ibis. Courtesy of the Art Institute of Chicago

Do you have the “curse of knowledge”? If you’re reading the Last Word on Nothing—meaning, if you’re a curious, highly literate, super smart person (also beautiful)—you probably do. The curse of knowledge refers to this phenomenon: Once you know something, it’s easy to forget that you used to not know it, and that a lot of other people still don’t. The curse of knowledge (at least how I hear it in my own head) is an ironic term. Imagine someone with their arm over their forehead, looking up in distress: “Woe is me! I am cursed with the burden of knowledge!” 

The curse of knowledge is sort of the opposite of the Dunning-Kruger effect, the finding that many people who know little about a subject will confidently overestimate how much they know. In the curse of knowledge, you overestimate how much other people know. 

Recognizing the curse of knowledge is important, especially for writers, editors, social media posters, scholars, researchers, chit-chatters, cartoonists, or communicators of any kind. 

I’ve edited for a lot of publications, and one of my favorite roles as an editor is to listen to a writer, who hopefully knows more about their subject area than I do, talk through a bunch of possible story ideas. I don’t know if you know this about science writers, but they know so much! It’s hard for them to find something they think is truly new, because not much is truly new to them. So they’ll often dismiss each story idea as they go, maybe because we covered a similar subject in 2023, or there was a story in a competing publication that’s aimed at experts, and anyway, everybody knows. The editor’s job to stop them when they hear the beginnings of a good story and say, “that’s interesting!” That’s interesting, and a lot of people in your audience doesn’t know this thing yet, and they will enjoy knowing it, so tell them.

Speaking in jargon is a type of curse of knowledge. It’s hard to notice jargon when you’re fluent in it, so communicators have to be scrupulous about explaining terms, especially ones that mean one thing in common language and a different thing among specialists. “Positive feedback” is a great example that climate communicator Susan Joy Hassol uses. Who doesn’t want positive feedback? Climate scientists, who use the term to refer to self-reinforcing cycles, like how when ice melts you get less reflection of sunlight, causing more ice to melt, causing less reflection. Same with experts who are “famous.” If you’re writing about them, go ahead and use both their names and include a reminder of who the heck they are.

The curse of knowledge is one reason I love “today I learned” as a hashtag and an approach to communication, a way to be humble and excited and generous with new knowledge all at the same time. At a meta-level, by highlighting something we just learned, we tell people who already knew that thing (because everybody knows) that not everybody knows it. A today-I-learned item is a new delight for some, and a reminder of the curse of knowledge for others.

The curse of knowledge is sort of a theory of mind problem, the problem of imagining what other people perceive and know and remember and care about. It’s much simpler to assume their mind is stuffed with the same stuff that’s in our mind. It’s a hard problem! How should we know what other people know? It takes a lot of reflection to figure out how to tell a story that is comprehensible to people who don’t know much about a subject and enjoyable and fresh for people who do. 

I’ve been thinking a lot about stories that fade from popular attention because a problem was solved; something was bad and then it was made better. Some people know that we fixed acid rain, saved the whales, created vaccines against cancer, and made apples taste better. But others don’t know, or have forgotten, or don’t know how good things happen, in part because mass media (for reasons) focuses on problems that haven’t been solved. And mass media has a huge curse of knowledge problem.

There’s no easy way out of the curse of knowledge, especially for writers (which includes anybody who writes anything). But it helps to talk to other people (editors, colleagues, friend-friends, or pocket friends you are connected with on social media) and ask questions. Does everybody know this already? This is kind of weird, right? Or is it boring? Or obvious? Is this helpful? Is this interesting? I’m telling you, it is. 

Science (journalism) metaphors: Chronaxie

In job ads for news writers, you’ll often see a reference to the ideal candidate having a “fast news metabolism”. It means: How much information can you cram into your eye holes and how quickly can you digest it all into a compact pellet of 400 words? (I apologise for taking the metaphor to its natural conclusion.)

The question of whether speed should be the primary objective in science news coverage is beyond the scope of this post. (I will offer that, anecdotally, all my own worst “news pellets” were generated in greatest haste.)

However, while I was in the trenches of electrophysiology history research for my book, I found an idea I liked a lot better than metabolism for how I think about my approach to science news: chronaxie. 

Even by electrophysiology standards, this term is a deep cut. It was introduced in 1909 by the French physiologist* Louis Lapicque, one of many physicians beguiled by the invention of a new tool known as the galvanometer, and its ability to eavesdrop on electrical activity inside the body. This was already revealing whole new worlds of health and infirmity: the electrocardiogram had recently decoded the secrets of the heart’s various failure modes; Hans Berger was just gathering the first of the electrical brain data that would lead to the invention of the EEG.

But Lapicque wanted to use electrical signals to probe muscle and nerve health more generally. So he introduced the word “chronaxie” as a measure of how well tissue responds to electrical stimulation. It gets quite complicated – it’s the minimum amount of time an electrical current must be applied to trigger a muscle twitch, which also depends on minimum effective current strength (ugh, I know). But to completely oversimplify it, it’s the unit of time that locates the robustness of your nerve-muscle circuit on a spectrum from “knee-jerk” to “half-dead”, effervescent to torpid, Leslie Knope to April Ludgate. This reaction speed and strength is the indicator light for the health of your muscle.

Continue reading →

My Favorite Halloween Tradition: Skiing!

I went cross-country skiing on Saturday. It was my fifth ski day of the new season, which is a welcome change after last year’s abysmal snowfall. We have another storm underway and with any luck, we should have some packed trails this week. Saturday also happened to be Halloween. I think of Halloween skiing as a Grand Mesa tradition, and since I’m a data nerd I have numbers to prove it.

Continue reading →