This is what a meaningless study looks like.

shutterstock_1765535

So many press releases land in my inbox that I don’t have time to read them all. But a recent release from the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) caught my eye — “Treatment by naturopathic doctors shows reduction in cardiovascular risk factors. Randomized controlled trial.”

This would be big news if it were true. Naturopathic physicians are eager for respect in the mainstream, and if a randomized, controlled trial really showed that naturopathic medicine could produce measurable results, this could give naturopaths some bona fide credibility.

At this point you may be asking, what exactly is “naturopathic medicine” anyway? According to the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, “Naturopathic physicians work with nature to restore people’s health.” Got that? They work with nature. Not to be confused with physicians that work against nature. For instance, oncologists who work to stop cancers made possible by genes that evolved in nature. Or infectious disease docs who fight parasites that have naturally co-evolved with their hosts. Continue reading

Unconnected Dots: Sport and Will Power

Screen-Shot-2013-05-02-at-7.32.56-AMClenching your muscles increases self-control. So does having a loud super-ego, or at least some form of inner monologue. Isolation disrupts our will power, as does having too much dopamine in our systems, like ADHD sufferers chronically do. Sugar boosts self-control. So does a short burst of exercise. For smokers, the same restorative effect happens when they smoke a cigarette.

Shirley Firth Larsson was a cross-country skier. She won the Canadian championships 29 times and competed – alongside her twin sister Sharon – in four consecutive Olympics (1972-84). She was indigenous Gwich’in from Inuvik, in Northern Canada, and she died of cancer a week ago.

We are less impulsive if we have long-term goals — something investors would be well served to keep in mind. Disciplined people are infectious: if we’re watching or even thinking of someone else who has good self-control, we stick to our goals. Disciplined people are also more satisfied with less. People with self-control deficiencies categorize more things as necessities. Muscle fatigue originates in the brain and can easily be influenced psychologically.

mouchet_lg

Shirley Firth Larsson was just one of the notable students who came out of Father Mouchet’s TEST program. That’s short for the Territorial Experimental Ski Program. Mouchet was a French resistance fighter. An oblate priest. A cross-country skiing enthusiast. An immigrant in 1946 to the Canadian Arctic. He thought the way to help indigenous students was to give them self-confidence and motivation through disciplined physical training.

Roy Baumeister and colleagues proposed a resource model of self-control – if we put in the effort to resist temptations in the morning, we might be more susceptible to them in the afternoon. If this is true, the key to better behavior would be in the removal of temptations. More recent work has suggested self-control has more to do with motivation and attendance. An area in the dorsal fronto-median cortex is activated every time we resist a temptation. When our attention shifts away from the task at hand, we start using all kinds of heuristics for our decisions, instead of really thinking things through or considering consequences.

There are fewer than 300 people in the Yukon fly-in community of Old Crow. January’s average daily low is -35˚C, not including wind chill. You couldn’t pay me enough to ski every morning before school in Old Crow. They started in primary school. Father Mouchet never got much religious traction in his largely Anglican community, but he is a hero to many. He was a rare gentle person in the lives of children who had been abducted from their families and sent to residential schools to be stripped of their culture. Now he’s 95 and says things like “I don’t think the child coming out of native society has the toughness that they used to have in those days.”

The Last Word on The Science Writers’ Handbook

Media Scrum_Thailand LWON is a group blog run semi-anarchically by 12 science writers. If you think that sounds like a recipe for chaos, just contemplate SciLance, an even more anarchic group of 35 science writers. Usually, SciLance is just a discussion group, so the chaos is relatively subdued. But last week, the writers of SciLance published their first group project – The Science Writers’ Handbook: Everything You Need to Know to Pitch, Publish and Prosper in the Digital Age. We thought we’d celebrate this triumph over entropy with blurred lines and convergent chaos. To wit: the 12 members of LWON interview the 3 LWONians who are also SciLancers. What could possibly go wrong? Continue reading

Guest Post: Death’s Eternal Logistics


I spent several hours on Sunday afternoon in what has to be the most charming cemetery in New York City. If I didn’t know what I was looking for, I would have missed its arched iron gate, tucked into 2nd Avenue just north of East 2nd Street, where the East Village meets the Lower East Side. Once through, I walked a short brick-lined alley into something that looks more Middle-earth than Manhattan: a half-acre plot of bright green grass, lined by a 12-foot marble wall.

It was warm and sunny. A few locals had come to the secluded spot to picnic, sunbathe and read. A gray-haired woman was sitting under a tree, painting the scene from a wooden easel. I walked past them and joined a group sitting in green plastic chairs. We were there for the owners’ meeting.
Continue reading

The Last Word

autistic brain

29 April – 3 May

This week, Richard’s new book came out! Oh, nothing, just the one he co-authored with Temple Grandin about the autistic brain. I don’t know how to put this, but he’s kind of a big deal.

Jessa and Ann ask him many questions. And yet, in middle of a busy book-signing schedule, Richard nonetheless finds the time to chart the incomprehensible distances of the universe in units of Justin Bieber.

Erika worries about some of the unforeseeable journalistic consequences of big data.

Cameron starts following an astronaut on Twitter and watches the world change.

And finally, Cassie is bored into a stupor by a recording of Alexander Graham Bell counting things. Because to the inventors of the new sound-recording technology, the most obvious application was accounting. You know, just like the PC’s killer app would be storing all those recipes.

 

 

Temple Grandin & a Neurotypical Write a Book

Richard and Temple Grandin have co-authored a book, The Autistic Brain: Thinking Across the Spectrum, which is just out and which you should definitely and immediately buy. Before you do, Jessa and Ann have some questions.

4389134342_0c62f4431e_bAnn: Richard, this subject is a departure for you. What is the subject, anyway? 

Richard: The immediate subject is the autistic brain. Hence the title: The Autistic Brain. But we also wanted the book to have a broader audience than the autistic community. As I always tell my writing students, if you want to illustrate the norm, use an anomaly—so in this case, the autistic brain is the anomaly that we use to investigate the whole nature of the brain.

Continue reading

Look Out My Window, There Goes Home

Chris Hadfield ‏@Cmdr_Hadfield  Tonight's Finale: The Moon ushering in the dawn over the Southeastern United States
Chris Hadfield ‏@Cmdr_Hadfield
Tonight’s Finale: The Moon ushering in the dawn over the Southeastern United States

Most of the people I follow on Facebook are friends from high school and college, so I usually see photos of kids, drinking establishments, and scenic shots of the West.  But recently I caught on to what 710,000 twitter followers and 219,354 Facebook friends (as of Tuesday) already knew–and started following Col. Chris Hadfield, a Canadian astronaut who has lived aboard the International Space Station since mid-December and became the ISS commander in March.

Hadfield has become a social media superstar, of the best kind: he’s shilling not for himself, but for space. He posts delightful YouTube videos that answer questions I didn’t even know I had: how astronauts sleep. How they cut their fingernails. Why they make their sandwiches with tortillas. How they cry. Continue reading

Bell, Berners-Lee, and the Promise of New Technology

More than a century ago, Alexander Graham Bell recorded his voice on a waxed cardboard disc at a laboratory in Washington DC. This week, we got to hear this scratchy recording—and Bell’s voice—for the first time.

Much of the recording involves Bell counting. He counts all the way up to 50, carefully enunciating each numeral. And then he begins counting by 10s. Then by 100s. Next comes a list of thousands. Then ten thousands. Then hundred thousands. Then he starts listing random numbers, like 4,530,870. Then . . . . zzzzzzz. I’m sorry. I fell asleep a little. It’s really boring. He enumerates for nearly four minutes.

Carl Haber, one of the scientists who helped extract Bell’s voice from the tattered disc, notes: “In those days of Edison and Bell, they thought recording was going to be important for accounting purposes or keeping business records. They may not have originally considered recording music.” Maybe that’s not quite true; an earlier phonograph recording did capture the sounds of a cornet. But there’s no doubt that when a technology is brand spanking new, we often have trouble predicting its usefulness. Continue reading